Sources
Works drawn on in A Multi-Agent Model of Major Technological Transitions.
20 sources in 2 categories
Civilisational Macrohistorical Development13
- Allan Dafoe ‘On Technological Determinism’ Science, Technology, & Human Values (2015)
- MacInnes, Garfinkel & Dafoe ‘Anarchy as Architect’ International Studies Quarterly (2024)
- Allan Dafoe ‘Value Erosion’ Future of Humanity Institute (2019)
- Daniel Schmachtenberger ‘The Emergence Model’ The Emergence Project (2017)
- Ken Wilber Sex, Ecology, Spirituality: The Spirit of Evolution (1995)
- Marvin Harris Cultural Materialism: The Struggle for a Science of Culture (1979)
- Daniel Schmachtenberger ‘New Economics, Part IV’ Civilization Emerging (2017)
- Peter Joseph The New Human Rights Movement: Reinventing the Economy to End Oppression (2017)
- Robert M. Sapolsky Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst (2017)
- Jared Diamond ‘The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race’ Discover (1987)
- Jared Diamond Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies (1997)
- Marshall Sahlins ‘The Original Affluent Society’ in Stone Age Economics (1972)
- Luke Kemp Goliath’s Curse: The History and Future of Societal Collapse (2025)
Evolutionary Process Misalignment7
- Luke Drago & Rudolf Laine ‘The Intelligence Curse’ Workshop Labs (2025)
- Jan Kulveit et al. ‘Gradual Disempowerment’ Alignment of Complex Systems Research Group (2025)
- Guive Assadi ‘Will Humanity Choose Its Future?’ Center for the Governance of AI (2023)
- Joe Carlsmith ‘Can Goodness Compete?’ (2025)
- Andrés Gómez Emilsson ‘The Universal Plot: Part I – Consciousness vs. Pure Replicators’ Qualia Research Institute (2017)
- Kristian Rönn ‘The Darwinian Trap’ LessWrong (2024)
- Scott Alexander ‘Meditations on Moloch’ Slate Star Codex (2014)
Civilisational Macrohistorical Development13
-
On Technological Determinism: A Typology, Scope Conditions, and a Mechanism
Science, Technology, & Human Values, 2015
Dafoe sorts the many versions of technological determinism into a typology and asks under what conditions technology really does drive social change. His answer is a mechanism he calls military-economic adaptationism: in a competitive international system, societies that adopt technologies conferring military and economic advantage prosper, and those that do not are outcompeted, conquered or forced to follow. The article supplies the structural half of this project’s model – the pressure that pushes each new technology stack across civilisation.
Developed in
-
Anarchy as Architect: Competitive Pressure, Technology, and the Internal Structure of States
International Studies Quarterly, 2024
The authors carry Dafoe’s mechanism from technology to the state itself. Competitive pressure between states narrows the range of domestic institutions any one of them can sustain, and technological change shifts which forms of state are competitive. A macrohistorical survey of competitively significant technologies shows the costs of anarchy to be larger than usually recognised: inventions that seem beneficial can lower human well-being by making inegalitarian states more competitive.
-
Value Erosion
Future of Humanity Institute, 2019
Dafoe names the risk that competition selects against good values. Wherever there is a trade-off between a value and competitive performance – among states, companies or, in time, autonomous AI systems – those who give the value up gain an edge, and pressure mounts on everyone else to follow, until values no one chose become entrenched.
-
The Emergence Model
Schmachtenberger describes a society as three interacting layers: its infrastructure, the technologies and material systems through which it meets its needs; its social structure, the institutions of politics, law and economics; and its superstructure, its shared values, beliefs and culture. A change in any layer pressures the others, but the deepest and most durable shifts begin in the infrastructure. The model gives this project its way of tracing how a new technology stack reshapes political economy and cultural psychology.
Derived from
-
Integral Theory
Wilber’s four-quadrant map holds that any whole has interior and exterior, individual and collective dimensions – experience, behaviour, culture and systems – and that none can be reduced to the others. It underlies the Emergence Model’s insistence that technological, institutional and cultural change be read together.
-
Cultural Materialism: The Struggle for a Science of Culture
1979
Harris divides every society into infrastructure, structure and superstructure, and argues that the material conditions of production and reproduction are the primary drivers of cultural change. It is the source of the Emergence Model’s three layers, and of the priority it gives to infrastructure.
New Economics, Part IV
Schmachtenberger traces how the economy came to be thought of, and managed, as something separate from the ecology that sustains it – an abstraction in which natural resources appear as inputs and their depletion as externalities. That separation, he argues, is part of what makes endless growth on a finite planet seem possible, and it is one of the roots of the present metacrisis.
-
The New Human Rights Movement: Reinventing the Economy to End Oppression
2017
Joseph argues that poverty, inequality and declining public health are not natural features of human life but products of an outdated socio-economic orientation built on scarcity, competition and endless growth. Structural oppression, on this account, follows from the economic system itself rather than from individual prejudice alone. The book informs this project’s view of the market as a historical construction, and of its effects as open to change.
-
Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst
2017
Sapolsky explains human behaviour across every timescale, from the neurons firing a second before an act to the evolutionary pressures of millions of years. Among the long-run influences he traces is the invention of poverty: how agriculture, surplus and hierarchy introduced inequality on a scale unknown to hunter-gatherers, with lasting effects on stress, health and behaviour. It grounds this project’s account of cultural-psychological adaptation in biology.
-
The Worst Mistake in the History of the Human Race
Discover, 1987
Diamond argues that the adoption of agriculture, long celebrated as humanity’s decisive step forward, was in many ways a catastrophe: it brought class, inequality, malnutrition and disease, making elites better off and most people worse off. The essay frames this project’s account of the Agricultural Revolution.
Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies
1997
Diamond asks why some societies came to dominate others, and finds the answer in geography, domestication and the technologies and diseases they produced – an account of how technological advantage reshapes the world.
-
The Original Affluent Society
In Stone Age Economics, 1972
Sahlins overturns the image of hunter-gatherers as living on the edge of starvation. Their wants were few and readily met, he argues, and they worked fewer hours than farmers or industrial workers: affluent not through abundance of goods but through the modesty of their needs. The essay underpins this project’s account of hunter-gatherer society as affluent in a minimalist sense, and of scarcity as something agriculture created.
-
Goliath’s Curse: The History and Future of Societal Collapse
2025
Kemp studies the rise and collapse of more than four hundred societies across five thousand years, and finds a recurring pattern: dominance hierarchies – “Goliaths” – grow by extraction and status competition among elites until they become fragile and fall, while more equal and democratic societies prove more resilient. He then asks what that history means for a globally connected civilisation armed with technologies of mass destruction. It sharpens this project’s question of whether the power-elite will steer the Intelligence Revolution towards or away from catastrophe.
Evolutionary Process Misalignment7
-
The Intelligence Curse
Workshop Labs, 2025
Drago and Laine draw an analogy with the resource curse, in which states that draw their wealth from oil rather than from their people have little reason to invest in them or answer to them. If powerful actors can draw their wealth and power from AI rather than from human labour, the same incentives could turn against most people – and the authors set out how the curse might be broken.
-
Gradual Disempowerment: Systemic Existential Risks from Incremental AI Development
Alignment of Complex Systems Research Group, 2025
The authors argue that existential catastrophe need not come from a sudden takeover. As AI incrementally replaces human labour and cognition across the economy, culture and the state, these systems lose the human participation that kept them implicitly aligned with human interests – and, each reinforcing the others, could leave humanity irreversibly disempowered.
-
Will Humanity Choose Its Future?
Center for the Governance of AI, 2023
Assadi defines an evolutionary future as one shaped by competition between actors towards a direction almost no one would have chosen – as, he argues, some of history’s greatest shifts, among them the rise of agriculture, were chosen by no one. Only a world government, strong multilateral coordination or a strong defensive advantage could halt such pressures, so confidence that humanity will choose its future requires confidence that one of them will hold.
-
Can Goodness Compete?
2025
Carlsmith examines the worry that competition rewards power, and power does not track goodness: if every chance to trade goodness for power makes winning more likely, a competitive future is one in which goodness loses. Yet constraining competition to protect it may demand forms of control that are oppressive, stagnant or brittle – a trade-off between a hyper-competitive future and a locked-in one.
-
The Universal Plot: Part I – Consciousness vs. Pure Replicators
Qualia Research Institute, 2017
Gómez Emilsson reads the story of life as a contest between consciousness and pure replicators – patterns that spread whatever the value of the experience they produce. Selection favours whatever replicates best, not whatever feels best, and he argues that a future left to such pressures could be dominated by replicators indifferent to the quality of conscious life.
-
The Darwinian Trap
LessWrong, 2024
Rönn names the selection pressures that drive agents to harm others for their own gain “Darwinian demons”, and traces how they fuel arms races for resources, power and intelligence that now threaten our future. He argues that the same pressures can be shifted – through global coordination that changes what is selected for.
-
Meditations on Moloch
Slate Star Codex, 2014
Alexander personifies the multipolar trap as Moloch: the logic by which competition forces every actor to sacrifice its values for competitiveness, in races to the bottom that no one wants and no one can escape alone. Left unchecked, he argues, it optimises away everything we care about, and only coordination strong enough to stand outside the competition can stop it.