Models

A genealogy of the frameworks that model civilisation as interacting structures. Marx’s base and superstructure set the pattern; Harris’s cultural materialism added a third layer, Wilber’s four quadrants a second axis, and Schmachtenberger’s Emergence Model brought the two together as the structures that condition human behaviour. The Complex Emergence Model and its Exo-Endo Structure carry the line forward: eleven structures, each shaping human agency from without and internalised within it.

The claim that competition is the mechanism for technological determinism is a special case of the theory of selectionism (also called Universal Darwinism). Selectionism generalizes the mechanism at the heart of evolutionary biology: variation and differential proliferation. In a population of varied forms, if some forms proliferate (reproduce, survive, grow) because of some characteristic, then that characteristic will be more abundant in future populations. Over time, these forms, called organisms in evolutionary biology and interactors more generally, will fit better with—will appear as if designed for—the criterion that determines superior proliferation (the “selection environment”).

Allan Dafoe, On Technological Determinism (2015)

    Each revolution adds a new layer to the civilisational tech stack, built on every layer before it. Point to a layer to see what it brought.

    Download diagram

      Three interacting layers, the deepest at the base. Point to a layer to see what it holds.

      Download diagram

        Two layers: the economic base, and the superstructure that rises on it. Point to a layer to see what it holds.

        Transecting

        Core

        Interfaces ‘Second Nature’

        Transecting

        Core

        Interfaces ‘Second Nature’

          Four structures, one in each quadrant: the inner and outer life of the individual, and of the collective. Point to a quadrant to see what it holds.

            Every whole has an inside and an outside, and is both an individual and part of a collective. Point to a quadrant to see what it holds.

            Timeline
            Cognitivec. 70,000 – 10,000 BCE Agriculturalc. 10,000 – 4000 BCEc. 10,000 BCE – 1760 CE Urbanc. 4000 BCE – 1540 CE Scientificc. 1540 – 1760 Industrialc. 1760 – 1870c. 1760 – 1950 Technologicalc. 1870 – 1950 Digitalc. 1950 – 2010c. 1950 – 2010 Intelligencec. 2010 – nowc. 2010 – now Cultural PsychologySuperstructure
            Shared myth and animism
            Ancestor cults, fertility gods and the first hierarchies
            Organised religion and divine kingship
            Reason, mechanism and a disenchanted nature
            Progress, individualism and nationalism
            Mass culture and consumerism
            Networked identity, self-expression and polarisation
            Post-humanism and accelerationism vs a pro-human and mature progress worldview
            Political EconomySocial Structure
            Small, mobile and broadly egalitarian bands
            Settled villages, private property and chiefdoms
            City-states, kings, taxes, law and markets
            Centralising states, standing armies and oceanic trade
            Industrial capitalism, wage labour and the nation-state
            Corporations, mass production and total war
            Global networks, platforms and the information economy
            Predicted fully automated economies, extreme power concentration and post-scarcity potential
            Tech StackInfrastructure
            Abstract thought, language and ranged weapons
            Domestication, farming and the storable surplus
            Writing, bronze, the wheel and the city
            Print, instruments and experiment
            Coal, steam and the factory
            Electricity, steel, chemistry and combustion
            The transistor, the computer and the network
            Machine learning, compute and AI agents
            Complex
            Emergence